A South Carolina church is currently facing an unwanted backlash from members of the public after being mistakenly identified as the church of pastor John-Paul “JP” Miller, whose controversial story has recently resurfaced on the spotlight following a Netflix documentary about the passing of his wife, Mica Miller in April 2024.
A minister, Mercy Baptist Church in Conway, South Carolina, says it has recently been receiving hostile messages, phone calls and social-media comments from people who apparently believe or misquoted their church is connected to JP Miller’s Mercy Church in Myrtle Beach. Church leaders later clarify that the two churches are completely separate and have no connections with each other. They went further to urged the members of the public to verify information before directing any anger, criticism toward the wrong congregation.

The confusion set in after JP Miller’s church in Myrtle Beach has faced protests and renewed public scrutiny following the release of Netflix’s documentary about Mica Miller’s 2024 death and her troubled relationship with the pastor. The renewed attention has brought protesters to Miller’s church, while online discussions surrounding the case have spread rapidly.
According to Mercy Baptist Church, the mistaken identity has created serious concerns for its congregation and the other activities operating under its property, including a daycare and children’s ministry. The situation highlights the consequences of misinformation spreading online, particularly when two organizations share similar names.

While public interest in the Mica Miller case remains high and watched. Mercy Baptist Church maintains that it has no connection to JP Miller and should not be confused or mistaken with their church. The church is asking people to confirm facts and identities before reacting or directing protests toward a congregation.


